Skip to content
Lenny's 🏦 Vault

Nine Monetization Plays: Four for Startups, Five for Scale-ups

by Madhavan Ramanujam on July 27, 2025

Madhavan Ramanujam's core thesis is that enduring businesses must master both market share and wallet share simultaneously - not choosing one over the other. This dual-engine approach is particularly critical for AI companies who need to get monetization right from day one.

The Market Share vs. Wallet Share Framework

  • Successful companies must dominate both market share and wallet share

    • Market share = customer acquisition
    • Wallet share = monetization and retention
    • "It is not a choice - you need to get better at both"
    • Equal attention (not necessarily equal effort) at all times

  • Most companies fall into a "single engine trap" by:

    • Growing at all costs while postponing monetization
    • Monetizing early but missing acquisition opportunities
    • Focusing only on a small loyal customer base

The AI Pricing Power Matrix

![AI Pricing Power Matrix with four quadrants based on Attribution and Autonomy]

Four pricing models based on attribution and autonomy:

  1. Seat-based/Subscription (Low Attribution, Low Autonomy)

    • For products where value is difficult to attribute and humans remain in the loop
    • Example: Traditional SaaS products

  2. Hybrid (High Attribution, Low Autonomy)

    • Base subscription plus consumption-based components
    • For products that clearly improve productivity but still require human involvement
    • Example: Cursor, Canva

  3. Usage-based (Low Attribution, High Autonomy)

    • Pay for what you consume
    • For autonomous backend/infrastructure products without direct KPI impact
    • Example: Cloud infrastructure

  4. Outcome-based (High Attribution, High Autonomy)

    • The "golden quadrant" with highest pricing power
    • Charge for specific outcomes delivered autonomously
    • Can capture 25-50% of value created (vs. 10-20% in traditional SaaS)
    • Example: Intercom Fin (charges 99¢ per AI-resolved ticket)
    • Currently only ~5% of companies use this model, expected to reach 25% in 3 years

Key Strategies for AI Companies

For Startups (Early Stage)

  1. Beautifully Simple Pricing

    • Create pricing that customers can easily understand and explain
    • Contextualize price based on value (e.g., Superhuman: "$1/day for 4 hours of productivity back per week")
    • Test: Can customers articulate your pricing strategy back to you?

  2. Frame POCs as Business Case Creation

    • Position POCs as co-creating an ROI model, not just testing functionality
    • Charge for POCs to filter out non-serious buyers
    • Make clear POC pricing is not indicative of final commercial terms
    • When pushed for pricing, give ranges tied to value (e.g., "pricing would be $500K-$1M based on the business case")

For Scale-ups

  1. Master Negotiations
    • Gives and Gets: Always ask for something when giving concessions
      • Example "get": Request a value audit every 6 months to document ROI
    • Value Selling: Create needs, build affirmation loops, co-create ROI models
    • Negotiation Tactics: Present options (e.g., fixed price vs. outcome-based) to shift focus from price to value

Common Traps to Avoid

  • Disruptor Traps: Landing but not expanding; winning market share but not holding it
  • Moneymaker Traps: Nickel-and-diming customers; pricing so high you hurt acquisition
  • Community Builder Traps: Missing new customer segments; training customers to expect more for less

The 20/80 Axiom

  • 20% of what you build drives 80% of willingness to pay
  • Ironically, that 20% is often the easiest to build
  • Many founders give away this 20% for free, then struggle to monetize the remaining 80%
  • MVP should mean "Most Valuable Product," not "Minimum Viable Product"

For AI Companies Specifically

  • Winners in AI must master monetization from day one due to:
    • Cost dynamics (need to manage costs from the start)
    • Value capture (avoid training customers to expect more for less)
  • If you anchor customers on low prices (e.g., $20/month), you'll struggle to increase later
  • AI enables attribution of value in ways traditional SaaS couldn't, creating pricing power

Revisiting Your Pricing Strategy

  • In traditional SaaS: Review pricing every 2 years
  • For AI companies: Review pricing at least annually
  • Price increases should be strategic and value-based
  • "If you have a prayer session for doing a 10% price increase, you have a terrible business" - Warren Buffett
View full episode